For at least a year before the summer of 2016, civilians and
fighters in rebel-held East Aleppo prepared for a siege they believed was both
avoidable and inevitable. Correctly, it turns out, they calculated that the
opposition’s bankrollers and arms suppliers—the United States, Turkey, Saudi Arabia,
and other “friends of Syria”—cared little for the well-being of civilians in
rebel-held areas. Through the spring, contacts inside Aleppo prepared for the
siege, expending minimal effort on appeals to the international community,
which they assumed would be futile.
For
all the world-weary resignation of the opposition fighters and other residents
of rebel Aleppo, they have a well-earned pride in what they’ve done. They’ve
maintained their hold on half of the jewel of Syria, and under withering
assault, have cobbled together an alternative to Bashar al-Assad’s rule. “From
the beginning of the revolution, we held Aleppo as the role model of the
liberated city, that holds free elections, has an elected city council, and
elected local committees that truly represent the people,” Osama Taljo, a
member of the rebel city council in East Aleppo, explained over the phone after
the siege began in earnest. “We insisted to make out of Aleppo an exemplar of
the free Syria that we aspire to.”
Unfortunately, Aleppo has
become an exemplar of something else: Western indifference to human suffering
and, perhaps more surprisingly, fecklessness in the face of a swelling
strategic threat that transcends one catastrophic war. The last few weeks have piled
humiliation upon misfortune for Aleppo, one of the world’s great cities, and
already a longtime hostage of Syria’s never-ending conflict. Aided by the
Russian military and foreign sectarian mercenaries, Syrian forces encircled
East Aleppo over the summer. Rebels briefly broke the siege, but Assad’s forces
fully isolated them just as Russia and the United States put the finishing
touches on a dead-on-arrival ceasefire agreement that, contrary to its stated
purpose, ushered in one of the war’s most violent phases yet.
Instead of a cessation of hostilities, Syria witnessed an acceleration of the
war against civilians, with East Aleppo as the showcase of the worst
war-criminal tactics Assad has refined through more than five years of war.
Sieges violate international law, as well as specific United Nations resolutions,
that, on paper, guarantee access to humanitarian aid to all Syrians but which
in practice the government has disregarded. Aleppo—the biggest prize yet for
Assad—has also been subjected to his most destructive assault. Throughout East
Aleppo, Syrian or Russian aircraft have ruthlessly bombed civilians, singling
out all healthcare facilities and first-responder bases. Bombs have ravaged
well-known hospitals supported by international aid groups, along with the
facilities of the White Helmets, the civil defense volunteers famous for
digging casualties from rubble.
As
if to test the proposition that the international community has just as little
concern for its own reputation as it does for the lives of Syrian civilians—nearly half of whom have been
displaced from their
homes nationwide—Russia apparently chose, on September 19, the seventh day of
the ceasefire, to bomb the first aid convoy en route to rebel-held Aleppo. That
decision will be remembered as a fateful one.
Russia and Syria were following
a timeworn blueprint: Use force to kill and starve civilians, then lie brazenly
to avoid responsibility. In this case, the evidence is too clear and the
trespass too toxic to let pass. So far, we’ve seen a sharp turn in rhetoric
from the UN and Washington. Sooner or later, whether in the twilight of the
Obama administration or in the dawn of his successor’s, we will see a much
harder “reset” in Western relations with Russia.For years, voices from Syria
have raised the alarm. After years of dithering, even some members of the
international community had the decency to follow suit, like Zeid Ra’ad Al Hussein,
UN High Commissioner for Human Rights. “The country is already a gigantic,
devastated graveyard,” al Hussein said this summer, warning
Syria’s belligerents that sieges and intentional starvation campaigns amount to
war crimes. “Even if they have become so brutalized [that] they do not care
about the innocent women, children, and men whose lives are in their hands,
they should bear in mind that one day there will be a reckoning for all these
crimes.” Belatedly, Western leaders are
joining the chorus. UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon, who avoided taking a
stand during years of violence against humanitarian organizations by the Assad
regime, now publicly accuses Syria and Russia of war crimes. On September 30,
the one-year anniversary of Russia’s direct entry into the war, Gareth Bayley,
Britain’s Special Representative to Syria, issued a broadside. “From Russia’s
first airstrikes in Syria, it has hit civilian areas and increasingly used
indiscriminate weapons, including cluster and incendiary munitions. Its
campaign has dramatically increased violence and prolonged the suffering of
hundreds of thousands of civilians,” he said, blaming Russia for at least 2,700
civilian deaths. “Russia has proved to be either unwilling or unable to
influence Assad and must bear its responsibility for the Assad regime’s
atrocities.”
America’s top diplomats, too, rail against Russia futilely. In a
recently leaked recording of a meeting between a ham-handed but apparently
sincere U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry and members of the Syrian
opposition, Kerry admitted that he lost the internal debate in the
administration for greater intervention, more protection of civilians, and a
stiffer stand against Russia’s triumphalist expansionism. But like a good
soldier, he has continued to flog a bad policy, pushing perhaps much too hard
on the small constituency of opposition Syrians who remain committed to a
pluralistic, unified, democratic Syria.
Perhaps
Russia has been searching for the West’s actual red lines all along, exploring
how far it could go in Syria without provoking any push back from the United
States and its allies. Maybe it finally found them after it bombed the UN aid
convoy in September. Only time will tell if the recent pitched rhetoric
translates into action.
One of the few consistent goals of U.S. policy in Syria over the
last year was to shift the burden of responsibility for the crisis, or even
guilt, to Russia. Throughout long negotiations, Washington has bent over
backwards to act in good faith, trusting against all evidence that Russia was
willing to act in concert to push Syria toward a political settlement.
America’s leaders today appear shocked that Russia was acting as a spoiler, a
fact clear to most observers long ago.
With the latest agreement in ashes—literally—and an ebullient
Russia convinced it will encounter no blowback for its war crimes, America has
a political chit in its hands. For now, Russia thinks it can achieve its
strategic goals by relentlessly destabilizing the international order and lying
as gleefully and willfully as the Assad regime. The United States helped
underwrite that international order when the UN came into being in 1945, laying
down moral markers on atrocities like genocide and war crimes, and crafting a
web of interlocking institutions that increased global security and prosperity.
As its primary enforcer, the United States also has been its primary
beneficiary.Now
that Russia, determined to reestablish its status after the humiliating
collapse of the Soviet Union, has pushed the United States into a humiliating
corner and weakened that international order, it is raising the stakes. Either
the United States will push back, or the disequilibrium will spread even
further. In either case, many thousands more Syrians will perish. As Bassam
Hajji Mustafa, a spokesman for the Nour al-Din al-Zinki Movement, one of the
more effective, if violent, rebel militias influential around Aleppo, put it,
“People have adapted to death, so scaring them with this siege is not going to work.”
Those who remain in Aleppo echo this refrain again and again: The last holdouts
have stayed out of conviction. It’s hard to imagine anything but death driving
them out. “If Aleppo falls and the world stays silent, then that will be the
end of the revolution,” Hajji Mustafa said.
In the end, Aleppo is not a story about the West; it is a
cornerstone of Syria and an engine of wealth and culture for the entire Levant.
Aleppo is the story of the willful destruction of a pivotal Arab state, a
center of gravity in a tumultuous region in sore need of anchors. It’s a story
of entirely avoidable human misery: the murder of babies, the destruction of
homes, the dismantling of a powerful industrial and craft economy.
The institutions of global governance are under strain and
international comity is frayed; as yet, however, none of the steps toward
dissolution are irreversible. Such shifts take place over decades, not months.
But the crisis in Syria presents the most acute test yet, and demands of the
United States an active, robust, and strategic response that reinforces its
commitment to the architecture of global governance—a system threatened by
spoiler powers like Russia and ideological attacks from nativists, the
right-wing fringe, and other domestic extremists in the West.
Ignoring its responsibilities in Syria—and opening the door for
Russia to pound away at the foundations of the international order—hurts not
only Syrians but the entire world. Perhaps, finally, Assad and his backers have
gone far enough to provoke an American defense of that indispensable order that
America helped construct.