Showing posts with label Dagestan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Dagestan. Show all posts

Saturday, 11 May 2013

Russia - Seeking A Kinder And Gentler Tyrant

Despite growing government persecution (often using the same methods the Soviets invented), pro-democracy and anti-corruption groups continue to hold public demonstrations. There is also growing discontent among senior government officials about the return to the Soviet past. Unlike the Soviet bureaucrats, the current ones are more aware of the outside world and understand that police states are not as economically successful as true democracies. Early in the Soviet period those with knowledge of the outside world were purged (and usually killed) from the leadership. Currently pro-soviet style officials believe that police-state powers make it easier to take down corruption. This is depicted as a fantasy by reformers, who point out that communist police states only remain uncorrupt for a short period before the rot sets in. The big problem in Russia is that for centuries the government has been a police state, one imposed by “enlightened” czars. The Soviets dumped the monarchy, expanded the police state and suppressed the market economy. That did not work, but there’s not general agreement in the current leadership as to exactly why. Many Russians just feel more comfortable with a “strong man” in charge, be they czar, communist or the deliberately macho Vladimir Putin. Most Russians will tolerate a tyrant if there is peace and prosperity.  
 
Russia and China continue to agree on trying to keep Syrian dictator Hafez Assad in power. Russia and China are both run by authoritarian governments. China is an old-school communist dictatorship while Russia is a democracy that is rapidly evolving into a police state. Russia and China agree that international intervention against dictatorships (as in Libya) is a very bad thing, as the same logic could be applied to Russia and China and cause all manner of international unpleasantness. Russia and China also believe that dictatorships are better able to control Islamic terrorism, something both Russia and China are more concerned about than democracy. Despite this attitude, Russia realizes that the Assad government is on the losing side here and continues to push for a negotiated settlement to the rebellion even if that means the Assad crew is replaced by a rebel coalition. What the Russians want is to be on good terms with the new government and have the possibility of selling more weapons to Syria and continue to use Tartus as a naval base for their new Mediterranean Squadron. At this point the Russian policy towards Syria is damage control. 
 
The Russian war against Islamic terrorists in the Caucasus continues, as part of a centuries-long battle with unruly peoples there. In the first three months of this year 73 Islamic terrorists were killed in the Caucasus, compared to 88 for the same period last year. Arrests are also down (from 133 to 88). What has gone up is finding hideouts (up from 24 to 26) and caches of weapons and equipment (up from 59 to 115). The counter-terrorism leadership believes they are winning. But that’s a relative term because this sort of disorder has been standard in the area for centuries.  The three provinces (Chechnya, Ingushetia, Dagestan) have been unusually violent for the last decade, leaving over 10,000 terrorists, civilians and security personnel dead. This is not unusual for the Caucasus, as the Russians occupied the area two centuries ago because of the chronic unrest and banditry (which preyed on nearby Russian territory.) Nothing much has changed in all that time and the three provinces still see up to a hundred killed and wounded each month because of terrorist activity. The Soviets had suppressed the violence for many decades (via mass punishment, deportations and lots more arrests) and once the Soviet police state was gone, the people of the Caucasus went back to their ancient ways. The current Russian government is also turning back to their authoritarian past, which does not bode well for the Caucasus. 
 
May 10, 2013: The government confirmed that it is still sending anti-aircraft missile systems to Syria and that this does not violate international sanctions as the deliveries are for orders placed before the sanctions were imposed. Most nations disagree with this, but no one wants to use force against Russia to halt the shipments. The Syrian rebels may do it themselves by shutting down the main airports in Syria. 
 
May 9, 2013: In the Caucasus police killed seven Islamic terrorists in Dagestan and one in Kabardino-Balkaria. 
 
April 28, 2013: In the Caucasus police killed two Islamic terrorists in Dagestan
 
April 26, 2013: In Moscow police arrested 140 Moslems (including 30 foreigners) on suspicion that they were involved with Islamic radical activities. This came after a long investigation of several Moslem groups in the city.

Friday, 26 April 2013

Russia - Sharing Some History With Boston

The April 15th terrorist in the United States (Boston) has made the world more aware of Russia’s terrorism problem in the Caucasus. The two Boston terrorists (the Tsarnaev brothers) were Chechens from Dagestan. Russia had alerted the American FBI and CIA about the elder brother in 2011. Russia had no hard evidence but their intelligence had picked up some data on the elder Tsarnaev brother’s interest in Islamic radicalism. In the United States the FBI and CIA are being grilled over why this vague tip did not result in the April 15 attack being prevented. One defense that will probably be heard (more likely from the CIA, which has long monitored the Caucasus) is that there are a lot Islamic radical Chechens these days, but few to them proceed to become Islamic terrorists and fewer still attempt to make attacks outside Russia. That has given Russia lots of problems in the last two decades.
 
Despite this formidable terrorist threat the security forces (local and national police plus specialized counter-terror forces from the police and military) have managed to reduce the terrorism in the Caucasus, but not eliminate it. Chechnya, Dagestan and Ingushetia are still full of nationalist and Islamic radical gangs that pursue criminal activities (theft, kidnapping, extortion) as well as frequent attacks on government officials. Local resentment of Russian rule goes back to the 19th century, when Russia conquered the Caucasus, in part to halt the raids by criminal gangs into Russia. It's an old problem made worse by the current popularity of Islamic terrorism among young Moslem men. The violence emanating from the Caucasus has long generated an animosity towards Caucasians (especially the Moslem ones) by most Russians. Refugees from the Caucasus violence often face violence and discrimination when they settle in other parts of Russia. 
 
The current situation developed when the Chechens tried, throughout the 1990s, to maintain their independence from Russia in the aftermath of the Soviet Union dissolving in 1991. But the Chechens could not govern themselves, and Chechnya became a hideout for numerous criminal gangs. These guys started a kidnapping, robbery and extortion crime wave all over southern Russia. In 1999, Russia, now led by Vladimir Putin, invaded, to reassert its authority and reduce the Chechen criminality in southern Russia and the Caucasus. Several years of bloody fighting followed, until a majority of the population agreed to shut down the gangsters. For the last few years, Chechnya has been at peace, at least by local standards. 
 
Many of the criminals and Islamic militants fled to neighboring "republics" (as the semi-autonomous ethnic enclaves in Russia are called); mainly Ingushetia to the west, and Dagestan to the east. 

Dagestan was able to handle the influx of Chechen gunmen, at least at first. But in Ingushetia, the violence kept getting worse. Some of the violence was just criminal activity, because tiny (population half a million) Ingushetia has an unemployment rate of over 50 percent. But there are also Islamic radicals who used to operate in Chechnya. And then there are a lot of guns in the hands of the population, so it's often difficult to tell who shot who and why.
 
The Russian government blames a lot of the unrest on local officials who, while pro-Russian (and dominated by a former KGB officials) are generally inept and corrupt. As these things go, the national government won't intervene unless the gangs based in Ingushetia began raiding into southern Russia. Corruption and feuds (between clans and ethnic groups) causes a lot of the violence, which is organized and focused via gangs of Islamic radicals. Most of the 4.2 million people in Chechnya, Ingushetia and Dagestan are Moslem, and never much liked Russians. Although the Russians have reduced the violence over the last decade, it persists, much to the embarrassment of the Russian government. This volatile mixing of organized Russians and unruly Caucasus minorities has been a problem for centuries (ever since the Russian empire reached the Caucasus two centuries ago.) Many of the largely Moslem Caucasian tribes saw it as their right to raid the Christian Russians (who had lots of stuff to steal). The Russians fought back, escalating to Cossacks and eventually the army and violence has persisted ever since. During World War II the Russians mistrusted the Chechens so much that they moved most of the Chechen population to Central Asia in 1944 (killing many in the process). Over the next two decades those exiles were allowed back to the Caucasus but both Russians and Chechens have not forgotten. That a couple of Chechens would carry out an attack in the United States (killing a woman, a child and a student from China) does not surprise a lot of Russians, and disturbs a lot of Chechens who would like to move away from their outlaw reputation.
What's surprising is that there aren't more attacks by Russian Moslems. Some 14 percent of Russians are Moslem, but only some of those in the Caucasus (where a few percent of the Russian population lives) are really into Islamic radicalism and terrorism. Relations between Slav Russians and the various ancient peoples of the Caucasus (which includes Christians Georgians and Armenians, as well as Moslem Chechens and dozens of other distinct ethnic groups) have been bad for centuries. But as the Russians discovered in the 1990s, even allowing Chechens to be independent did not solve the problem.
 
April 25, 2013:  For the first time a Russian Air Force pilot flew the new Russian stealth fighter the PAK-FA (comparable to the American F-22).  All previous flights had been handled by test pilots. The PAK-FA is a joint development deal with India and is expected to start production in three years. Six years ago India agreed to partner with Russia in the development and production of a “Fifth Generation Fighter.” The Russian-Indian effort is meant to build a fighter that can give the American F-22 some competition. The PAK-FA looks a lot like the F-22. The 37 ton PAK-FA is about the same weight as the F-22, and has a similar shape. 
 
April 24, 2013: In the south (Dagestan) police killed two Islamic terrorists. 
 
April 23, 2013: The Russian Navy held several days of training exercises in the Caspian Sea. Some twenty patrol boats, larger warships and support vessels were involved. This was not just to improve skills, but to send a message to Iran that Russian was still the primary naval power in the Caspian. This message was also to calm Russian ally Azerbaijan, which Iranian officials recently announced ought to be annexed by Iran. 
 
April 22, 2013:  Islamic terror groups in the Caucasus announced that they had nothing to do with two Chechens carrying out a terror attack in the United States last week. The policy of Islamic terrorists in the Caucasus has been to concentrate on attacking Russia, But individual terrorists from the Caucasus have showed up in many other areas (Pakistan and Syria in particular.)
 
April 18, 2013: President Putin threatened to fire several of his department ministers if they did not find ways to carry out social spending increases he had ordered. Letting incidents like this go public, and actually carrying out increases in social spending, is one way Putin maintains his high poll numbers. Putin also denied creating a new version of the Soviet era dictatorship, but more Russians continue to openly complain about the growing use of police state tactics. 
 
April 17, 2013: A former Russian Army lieutenant was sentenced to three years imprisonment for corruption while he was a company commander two years ago. The bad lieutenant took bribes and extorted money from his subordinates. While extreme, this sort of thing is not unusual in the Russian military. 
 
April 15, 2013: Russia has begun its semi-annual conscription for the armed forces. This time the military needs to obtain 153,000 recruits. Because of a shrinking population the government was forced to allow fewer exemptions (especially for students). Avoiding conscription has turned into a big business with brokers available to advise parents on whom to bribe and how much to offer to keep their son out of uniform